Il San Pietro sits a couple of minutes outside Positano, which is exactly why it works. You look back at the town stacked up the hillside rather than living in its crowds, and a free shuttle runs into the centre at all hours when you want a wander. Every room is different, with local hand-painted tiles and a furnished terrace facing the sea.
The days organise themselves around the water. A lift cut into the cliff drops you from the lobby to the beach club and the tennis court at sea level, and from May to mid-October there is a free two-hour boat trip along the coast most mornings, with a swim stop. Dinner at Zass is the formal event of the week; Carlino, down by the water, is where we would eat on the other nights.
It is not a place for small children, who need to be 10 or over, and it closes for the winter. The cliff setting also means plenty of steps between terraces, so anyone with limited mobility should tell us before we choose a room. For couples and families with teenagers who want the Amalfi Coast at its most polished without staying in the middle of Positano, it is our first suggestion.